Federal Court Rules For Young Plaintiffs In Climate Change Suit


With help and guidance from Our Children’s Trust, a group of young plaintiffs have brought suit in federal district court in Oregon against President Obama, the fossil fuel industry, and various government agencies claiming that they have not done enough to protect them from the effects of global climate change. The central issue in the law suit is both simple and innovative. They claim the US Constitution guarantees them the right to life and liberty. Degrading the environment deprives them of both, they claim.

climate change suitl

The suit was brought because the young plaintiffs claim only the courts can enforce their constitutional rights in the face of a bunch of know nothings in Congress who refuse to act to protect the citizens of America. One of the plaintiffs is James Hansen, the former NASA scientist who was one of the first to sound the alarm about global warwing. His young grandaughter is also a plaintiff.

On November 11, US District Judge Ann Aiken sitting in Eugene, Oregon ruled that the suit could proceed. The fossil fuel companies marshaled an army of high priced legal talent to argue that the suit should be dismissed. Judge Aiken disagreed. “Federal courts too often have been cautious and overly deferential in the arena of environmental law, and the world has suffered for it,” she wrote in her decision.

She declared that the effects of man-made climate change are “undisputed” and support the plaintiffs’ efforts to hold national powers accountable for the damages caused by global warming. She wrote, “This action is of a different order than the typical environmental case. It alleges that defendants’ actions and inactions — whether or not they violate any specific statutory duty — have so profoundly damaged our home planet that they threaten plaintiffs’ fundamental constitutional rights to life and liberty.”

The timing of the court’s decision is interesting, coming as it does in the same week that saw Donald Trump win the presidency. Trump has repeated called climate changed a hoax and has vowed to prevent the United States from honoring its commitments made at the COP 21 climate change conference in Paris last December.

Trump has now named Myron Ebell — a notorious climate change denier — to head the Environment Protection Agency. Ebell’s mission will be to dismantle as many of the EPA’s existing rules and regulations as possible. Clearly the young plaintiffs can expect no help from the next administration.

What will happen if the plaintiffs win? The answer to that is too speculative to predict. But at least these courageous young people are willing to stand up to the federal government and the fossil fuel industries to force them to stop poisoning the air they breathe and the water they drink and the land they live on. Good for them and godspeed.

Source: Motherboard

About the Author

I have been a car nut since the days when Rob Walker and Henry N. Manney, III graced the pages of Road & Track. Today, I use my trusty Miata for TSD rallies and occasional track days at Lime Rock and Watkins Glen. If it moves on wheels, I'm interested in it. Please follow me on Google + and Twitter.
  • curly4

    Look out industry now just anyone can sue you costing you millions and maybe even stopping you form doing your business!

    • Steve Hanley

      Well, it’s a long road ahead for these young litigants, but it’s a start.

      • curly4

        True, Steve, but since they are now on the correct road they will find many problems to sue over

        • Steve Hanley

          No doubt about that. However, all of these legal challenges all end up in one place, the US Supreme Court. If the Trumpeter has its way, that august body will be a solid bulwark of ultra conservative ideologues for the next 20 – 30 years.

          I warned people that the SC was the real issue in this past election, but did they listen? No. They were all to busy being angry to pay attention to what was important.

          The United States will now be cursed with the toxic fallout of Trumpism for the next generation or so.

  • Antony Berretti

    I would add Steve that is is the best piece of news to come from the States this past 7 days! The hell it will be a tough and very bitter battle, but kids all across the US can add their voices to this action. Would not want tone in Trumps place if they take their action to DC after Jan 17?

  • Steve Hanley

    That is so. There have also been successful suits in state courts in Washington and Massachusetts.