Activism no image

Published on August 24th, 2009 | by Joe Berlinger

12

Bearing Witness: Why A Small Film Called Crude Matters in a $27 Billion Lawsuit Against Chevron

[social_buttons]

Editor’s Note: This is a guest post by filmmaker Joe Berlinger, director of Crude. For more information visit the Crude film website.

During the summer of 2005, a charismatic American environmental lawyer named Steven Donziger knocked on my Manhattan office door. He was running a $27 billion class-action lawsuit on behalf of 30,000 Ecuadorean inhabitants of the Amazon rainforest and was looking for a filmmaker to tell his clients’ story.

Since I am not known as an environmental filmmaker — my last film, “Metallica: Some Kind of Monster,” was a warts-and-all portrait of a heavy metal band in crisis — I was a little surprised that Donziger had sought me out to me to make his pitch.

The story the lawyer told me was indeed shocking: From the mid-1960s until the early 1990s, Texaco (now Chevron) dumped 18 billion gallons of oil and toxic waste into the Amazon rainforest of Ecuador, creating a 1,700-square-mile “cancer death zone” the size of Rhode Island. The plaintiffs he represented alleged that birth defects, leukemia, miscarriages and other ailments were plaguing the people of the region, and the Amazon itself — one of the few places on Earth to survive the last ice age — was gasping for breath under the strain of oil exploitation.

Crude Movie

But, while it seemed like a heartbreaking situation that someone should document, I was skeptical that it could be a feature-length film that I should get involved in.

I explained to Donzinger that I believe the best way to serve the truth is to explore a situation from all sides without overtly revealing the filmmaker’s viewpoint, allowing each audience member to come up with his or her own conclusion about the events they are witnessing onscreen. This is the opposite approach of the standard environmental and human rights advocacy film in which a single point of view is clearly conveyed, often just preaching to the converted instead of winning people over through the active process of weighing the pros and cons. I was also (selfishly) concerned with who would pay for a subtitled documentary about indigenous rainforest dwellers in a faraway country that many Americans know nothing about. Since my first film “Brother’s Keeper,” I had vowed never to start a film unless there was a budget or a distribution outlet in place.

oil spill

On my first trip to Ecuador, I was shocked by the foul petrochemical sludge and toxic water that, for decades, had been dumped into open pits or directly into the area’s rivers and streams, and was surprised at the scant press coverage this story had received in the U.S. I talked with people who were sick and dying from cancer and other maladies — some of the 30,000 settlers and indigenous people who are signed onto the lawsuit and who call themselves “los afectados” (the affected ones). I also met Pablo Fajardo, the remarkable 35-year-old lawyer who was once a poor manual laborer in the oil fields. Pablo still lives in relative poverty, but today, working with Donziger, he is the lead attorney in the largest oil-related environmental lawsuit on the planet.

Crude Movie

Much of my previous work, such as Brother’s Keeper, Paradise Lost and Metallica: Some Kind of Monster, has sought to break down stereotypes and preconceived notions and probe beneath the surface of people and situations. In the real world, things aren’t black and white, and this is how I approached this story, as well. An indigenous Amazonian leader doesn’t just show up at a Chevron shareholders’ meeting and confront the CEO all by himself – he is coached by a Harvard-educated attorney. The Ecuadorean plaintiffs can’t spend fifteen years in court on their own – they need a high-powered Philadelphia law firm specializing in class action lawsuits to pay for the investigations that Ecuadorean law requires – and that law firm stands to profit from any judgment. The attorneys for both the oil company and the plaintiffs compete for media attention, but the spotlight on the case gets brighter when celebrity activists Trudie Styler and Sting come on board. Yet here too I hope the film topples the usual clichés, as Trudie proves herself to be anything but a token “rent-a-celeb,” delivering on a promise she makes to help ease the suffering of the people.

At the last moment, we were able to convince Chevron to participate in the film, which is a critical component of the balanced portrait we always hoped to create. It took nearly a year of negotiation, but in the eleventh hour, just as we were readying our rough cut to submit to the Sundance Film Festival, the company offered up two spokespeople to sit for interviews, elevating the film to a new level. And while some people may initially perceive the representatives from Chevron as simply being part of a “big bad oil company,” they come across as real human beings who make a number of very intriguing legal and scientific claims.

Crude Movie

Despite these ambiguities, the film never loses sight of what has true value. In the midst of the messy, murky world of this case, there are still good guys to root for, and even a clear hero in Pablo Fajardo. Cool and calm in the jungle, surrounded by press and adversarial lawyers, Pablo is unwavering in his insistence that you cannot put a price tag on human life, clean air and water or a healthy planet, regardless of who is right or wrong in the lawsuit.

One of the themes of the film is that in a world in which the Exxon Valdez judgment took nearly two decades to appeal, it will be generations before this case is fully resolved. So while the lawyers argue and various parties jockey for position with the media, the indigenous people who have lived in harmony with nature on these lands for millennia continue to suffer. That’s why the last scene of the film shows a group of Cofán Indians heading down river to an uncertain future. At the end of the journey of the film, Crude comes back to where it started, bearing witness to the lives of these people and the once-rich land they live on, leaving us to think about why this story matters to us all.

MORE:

  • Crude Twitter: http://twitter.com/crudethemovie
  • Info About Film: http://www.crudethemovie.com/about-2

Key Premieres:

CRUDE opens in select cities beginning September 9th – 22nd at the IFC Center:

  • Los Angeles: September 18th -24th
  • San Francsco: September 25th -October 1st
  • Washington, D.C.: October 23rd -29th

For a full list of cities and screening dates please visit the Crude website.


Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , ,


About the Author



  • http://www.technologyslice.com.au Technology Slice

    That is absolutely disgusting how a big company is exploiting those poor people and the environment. These people have to live in sickness and pain so Chevron can save money on waste disposal.

  • http://www.technologyslice.com.au Technology Slice

    That is absolutely disgusting how a big company is exploiting those poor people and the environment. These people have to live in sickness and pain so Chevron can save money on waste disposal.

  • Antonio Andolini

    Now I HATE big oil and Goldman Sachs.

  • Antonio Andolini

    Now I HATE big oil and Goldman Sachs.

  • Renèe

    Quando finirà di fare da padrona la Chevron?

    Questa non è casa sua!!!

    Un disastro ecologico simile dovrebbe subito far riflettere il Pianeta sull’effettivo bisogno del petrolio!

    Cosa aspettiamo a usare fonti rinnovabili e green?

    La TERRA è la ns Madre !!!

    Renèe from Italy

  • Renèe

    Quando finirà di fare da padrona la Chevron?

    Questa non è casa sua!!!

    Un disastro ecologico simile dovrebbe subito far riflettere il Pianeta sull’effettivo bisogno del petrolio!

    Cosa aspettiamo a usare fonti rinnovabili e green?

    La TERRA è la ns Madre !!!

    Renèe from Italy

  • http://www.biodiversivist.com Russ Finley

    Big companies will, if allowed to do so, take advantage of little people, whether they are fossil oil companies or palm oil companies. Someone needs to also do a documentary on what biofuels are doing to the poor and the planet.

  • http://www.biodiversivist.com Russ Finley

    Big companies will, if allowed to do so, take advantage of little people, whether they are fossil oil companies or palm oil companies. Someone needs to also do a documentary on what biofuels are doing to the poor and the planet.

  • Dorian

    If you do anything over the next few weeks, bring a group to go see this movie. By supporting films like Joe Berlinger’s Crude, you encourage light to be shone in dark places. Without an audience in the bigger cities, a film of this magnitude will not get seen throughout the rest of the country…like a tree that falls in the rainforest if no one is there. Get off your behind and put it in a theater seat.

  • Dorian

    If you do anything over the next few weeks, bring a group to go see this movie. By supporting films like Joe Berlinger’s Crude, you encourage light to be shone in dark places. Without an audience in the bigger cities, a film of this magnitude will not get seen throughout the rest of the country…like a tree that falls in the rainforest if no one is there. Get off your behind and put it in a theater seat.

  • Uncle B

    Arrogant waste of a resource flow! In an America about to face the highest ever gasoline prices,with taxes soaring to pay for bailouts ans astounding inflation rates due to fiat money printing, the “White Shirts” that initialed this wastefulness will likely be sent out by corporatist leaders, with drinking straws and small cups to do penance and recover their foolish arrogant ignorant waste! The Uber-Rich Multi-national shareholders will be incensed at this lack of skill in recouping all of value on their investment venture here! “18 billion gallons of oil and toxic waste” = profits lost due to incompetence! Watch the Chinese wells! They won’t waste a damn thing! Look to Turkmenistan! China has a 350 mile gas line that is the most modern in the world, and they are not polluting! They are too wise and too competent to waste! Only Ass-hole Americans have this slash and kill, cowboy, devil may care attitude, and for a factual example of their ineptitude at engineering anything, throw away half the heat from their reactors as we speak, while Sweden grows greenhouses full of food with theirs! American Engineering schools lost the auto supremacy of the U.S. too! They are ass-holes! all they do good is WWII guns! Take a look at the mess these assholes left in the Canadian Tar Sands with their “Advanced Technologies” and “Supreme Knowledge and arrogant smart ass know it all notions from hell” and Michigan school desks! Even meager humanure, considered a resource flow in some Asian (superior technologists) countries and these hopeless “Cost Plus” air-conditioned over-weight jerks waste resources, destroy good land! Only from American schools, only as directed by accountancies equations, only for American projects, where the corporatists have taken over and ruined the whole show! One more decade of this style slovenly, arrogant, waste and America will go down never to rise again, in its own sludge of environmental disaster! We are not omnipotent in the world! China, Asia India, are! we sink like a stone squirming in accountancies manipulations to the bottom! Witness: Gold, a full $1200.00 U.S. for a paltry troy oz. and dishonesty even at Fort Knox! See: http://www.viewzone.com/fakegold.html

    China no longer willing to lend to the U.S. – too crooked to be trusted! America about to face its comeuppance as the dollar falls and China buys world’s finite resources and manufactures them into products for all! Fields of wasted oil, spoiled land! American trademark!

  • Uncle B

    Arrogant waste of a resource flow! In an America about to face the highest ever gasoline prices,with taxes soaring to pay for bailouts ans astounding inflation rates due to fiat money printing, the “White Shirts” that initialed this wastefulness will likely be sent out by corporatist leaders, with drinking straws and small cups to do penance and recover their foolish arrogant ignorant waste! The Uber-Rich Multi-national shareholders will be incensed at this lack of skill in recouping all of value on their investment venture here! “18 billion gallons of oil and toxic waste” = profits lost due to incompetence! Watch the Chinese wells! They won’t waste a damn thing! Look to Turkmenistan! China has a 350 mile gas line that is the most modern in the world, and they are not polluting! They are too wise and too competent to waste! Only Ass-hole Americans have this slash and kill, cowboy, devil may care attitude, and for a factual example of their ineptitude at engineering anything, throw away half the heat from their reactors as we speak, while Sweden grows greenhouses full of food with theirs! American Engineering schools lost the auto supremacy of the U.S. too! They are ass-holes! all they do good is WWII guns! Take a look at the mess these assholes left in the Canadian Tar Sands with their “Advanced Technologies” and “Supreme Knowledge and arrogant smart ass know it all notions from hell” and Michigan school desks! Even meager humanure, considered a resource flow in some Asian (superior technologists) countries and these hopeless “Cost Plus” air-conditioned over-weight jerks waste resources, destroy good land! Only from American schools, only as directed by accountancies equations, only for American projects, where the corporatists have taken over and ruined the whole show! One more decade of this style slovenly, arrogant, waste and America will go down never to rise again, in its own sludge of environmental disaster! We are not omnipotent in the world! China, Asia India, are! we sink like a stone squirming in accountancies manipulations to the bottom! Witness: Gold, a full $1200.00 U.S. for a paltry troy oz. and dishonesty even at Fort Knox! See: http://www.viewzone.com/fakegold.html

    China no longer willing to lend to the U.S. – too crooked to be trusted! America about to face its comeuppance as the dollar falls and China buys world’s finite resources and manufactures them into products for all! Fields of wasted oil, spoiled land! American trademark!

Back to Top ↑